Mitchell Mesenbrink, a standout wrestler for Penn State, has demonstrated exceptional dominance in the 165-pound weight class. In the 2024-2025 season, he achieved a 20-2 record, with a 14-1 dual record and a 7-1 conference record. Notably, he secured second place at the Big Ten Championships and clinched the championship at the Soldier Salute. His performance included 11 technical falls and one pin, underscoring his aggressive wrestling style. citeturn0search5
Mesenbrink’s prowess was further evident during the 2023-2024 season, where he finished with a 26-1 record. He clinched the Big Ten title and advanced to the NCAA finals at 165 pounds, a weight class featuring three past NCAA champions. His relentless and aggressive approach earned him the 2024 NCAA Division I Freshman of the Year award. citeturn0search3
In contrast, Mikey Caliendo, representing Iowa, has faced challenges against Mesenbrink. In their recent encounters, Mesenbrink defeated Caliendo with scores of 23-7 at the Big Ten Championships and 17-9 at the NCAA Championships. These results highlight Mesenbrink’s superior performance over Caliendo in their head-to-head matchups. citeturn0search5
Caliendo, however, has had notable achievements of his own. In the 2023-2024 season, he earned All-American honors by placing fourth at the NCAA Championships and secured third place at the Big Ten Championships. His season record stood at 28-6, with a 11-3 dual record and a 9-6 mark against ranked opponents. citeturn0search2
While Mesenbrink’s recent victories over Caliendo have been decisive, both wrestlers have distinguished themselves in the collegiate wrestling arena. Mesenbrink’s aggressive style and consistent performance position him as a leading figure in his weight class, whereas Caliendo’s resilience and past accomplishments reflect his significant contributions to Iowa’s wrestling program.
